BBC slammed over Canadian dispute

Locked-out union members picket CBC's HQ in Toronto.

Locked-out union members picket CBC's HQ in Toronto.

Unions have condemned the BBC for taking sides in an industrial dispute at the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.

Since CBC locked out its 5,500 union workforce on Monday August 15, news programmes from BBC World have been broadcast across Canada to fill gaps in schedules caused by the lockout.

CBC's main TV channel has replaced all its normal bulletins with feeds from the BBC, and its news channel has increased the number of BBC-provided bulletins it transmits to six a day.

In a letter sent to the BBC sent today, August 17, BECTU and the NUJ accused the Corporation of undermining union members in Canada by helping to keep CBC on the air, and warned that serious damage was being done to the BBC's reputation.

Lise Lareau, President of the Canadian Media Guild (CMG) which represents the locked-out workers, said: "The BBC runs the risk of losing its international status as an impartial and highly regarded news service by so openly being associated with one side in a dispute between CBC and its staff. People in Britain and elsewhere should be concerned about this."

The BBC's two main unions have demanded an urgent meeting with top managers to discuss the issue, and will be urging the Corporation to cut the lifeline that has allowed CBC to avoid blank screens while its staff stand on picket lines.

Martin Spence, BECTU Assistant General Secretary, said: "The BBC's support for a broadcaster who has locked out its staff rather than talk to them can only make CBC management bolder, and will probably lengthen a dispute that should never have happened in the first place. The last thing the BBC needs is this kind of damage to its reputation at a time when the debate about its own future is beginning".

CBC's move to lock out its workforce came after talks between Canada's main public broadcaster and CMG collapsed due to differences over the use of staff on short term contracts.

Managers wanted the union to accept a new collective agreement which would allow the level of contract staff in CBC, currently almost 30% according to the Guild once casuals were included, to be significantly increased, allowing contract workers to replace permanent staff as vacancies occur.

By comparison, the BBC itself consciously reduced the incidence of contract working, with union support, from 24% of its workforce in 2000 to less than 14% by 2004.

CBC management have been accused by the Canadian Media Guild of demanding impossible concessions from the union as part of a pre-conceived plan to engineer a workforce that was "mostly temporary". The union has also emphasised the long-term damage that will be done to public service broadcasting in Canada if CBC protracts the current lockout.

More information from Lise Lareau: 00 1 416 591 5333

Letter from BECTU and NUJ to BBC management

Gillian Alford
BBC People
London

17 August 2005

Dear Gillian,

We are writing on behalf of the NUJ and BECTU to seek an urgent meeting to discuss the use of BBC material by CBC management during the course of the current dispute at the corporation.

BBC journalists in Canada and Canadian unions allege that the BBC is supplying additional material to CBC which is being used to replace regular news programmes and is thereby taking sides in the industrial dispute and undermining the rights of Canadian media workers.

We understand there have been a number of newspaper articles in Canada critical of the BBC's role in the dispute and questioning its partisan approach in being seen to back the management position.

A number of BBC workers are already refusing to do handoffs for CBC. Some have sought advice about withdrawing their permission for their material to be used by the BBC if it is then going to be used by CBC.

BECTU and the NUJ would like an urgent meeting to discuss the dispute and the BBC's role. In particular we want to know if the BBC has received any requests from CBC management to increase the use of BBC material, what permissions have been given, what financial considerations are involved, and what action the BBC proposes to take to ensure that the BBC is not seen to be taking sides.

We look forward to your early response.

Yours sincerely

Jeremy Dear
General Secretary, NUJ

Martin Spence
Assistant General Secretary, BECTU

17 August 2005